Build Stakeholder Trust Before You Need It
A company can make the right strategic decision and still damage the relationships it needs to succeed.
This is the growing risk for Minnesota businesses navigating an extraordinary period of change. Artificial intelligence is transforming operations and customer behavior. Workforce capabilities are shifting. Economic pressures, regulatory changes and leadership transitions are forcing organizations to rethink how they do business.
Leaders are investing enormous energy preparing their organizations for these changes. They’re developing strategies, evaluating technology, restructuring operations and making difficult financial decisions. But are they spending enough time preparing the people whose trust and support they’ll need to succeed?
In recent Tunheim conversations with business executives, a common challenge keeps emerging: The business may be ready to change before the relationships that sustain it are ready to evolve.
When the right strategy isn’t enough
Consider a retailer investing in artificial intelligence to improve merchandising, customer targeting and profitability. The strategy makes sense. The technology promises better decisions and greater efficiency. Leadership understands why the investment is necessary. But an experienced retail executive recently shared a different concern with us: What happens when employees believe in the strategy but lack the skills or adaptability to execute it?
It’s an important distinction. Agreement isn’t the same as readiness. And the challenge extends well beyond employees.
Customers may love a retailer but become frustrated when changes affect the shopping experience they’ve come to expect. Employees may believe in their company’s future but worry about whether they have the skills to succeed in it. Communities may support a health care organization but resist changes to services they’ve depended on for years.
These aren’t necessarily signs that leadership has chosen the wrong direction. They may be signs that critical relationships aren’t transforming as quickly as the business.
We’ve begun calling this period The Breaking Point: when the business must change faster than the relationships that sustain it are evolving. The danger is that leaders may not recognize the gap until it begins affecting performance, reputation or their ability to execute the strategy.
Trust cannot be built on demand
Most organizations become intensely focused on stakeholder relationships when a major announcement, difficult decision or public controversy is approaching. By then, they’re often asking people to accept changes to a relationship built over many years.
Consider a manufacturer introducing automation, a retailer changing its customer experience or a health care system restructuring services. Each may have compelling reasons for its decisions. But employees, customers and communities experience those decisions through their own expectations and histories with the organization.
A well-crafted announcement can explain what is changing. It cannot instantly create the trust needed to navigate that change. That trust is built through consistent behavior, honest conversations and a demonstrated understanding of what matters to the people who depend on the organization.
Those conversations are most valuable before leadership urgently needs support.
This doesn’t mean giving every stakeholder a vote on every business decision. Leaders must still make difficult choices. It means understanding how those choices will change important relationships, and preparing those relationships alongside the business.
Three questions leaders should ask now
Boards and executive teams routinely examine financial readiness, operational readiness and strategic risk. Stakeholder readiness deserves the same attention.
Three questions can help:
Which relationships will have to change for your strategy to succeed? Identify the employees, customers, partners, investors and communities whose expectations may need to evolve.
Are you confusing support for your strategy with readiness to execute it? People may understand and endorse a direction without having the capabilities, confidence or resources to make it successful.
What early signals would tell us a critical relationship is falling behind? Financial and operational dashboards measure results. Leaders also need ways to recognize changing expectations, weakening confidence and emerging relationship gaps before they become business problems.
None of this requires slowing down necessary change. In fact, understanding stakeholder readiness can help organizations move faster, with fewer surprises and less resistance.
Minnesota businesses have a long history of navigating disruption and reinventing themselves. The next generation of successful companies will need to do more than adapt their business models. They’ll need to help the relationships that sustain those models evolve as well.
Because when an organization reaches a moment that truly tests the confidence of its employees, customers or communities, the strength of those relationships will depend on what leadership did long before that moment arrived.
The best time to build stakeholder trust is when you don’t urgently need it.