The Next Minnesota Model: A Framework That Lets Everyone Invest What They Have

The Next Minnesota Model: A Framework That Lets Everyone Invest What They Have

Not equity, not cash up front: a share of revenue, paid as the company grows. More of us get to invest, and more of us share in the upside.

At my software studio, one request comes in almost every month. A company has paying customers and knows exactly what it needs to build next. The founder wants a number: what will it cost, so she can figure out how to pay for it? Then, with time and money already tight, she spends six months on financing instead of building.

The economics of scaling a company look nothing like they did five years ago. The cost of building has collapsed, so a small team can get a product to market and start selling. Venture capital, meanwhile, is backing fewer companies at bigger checks. Most Minnesota companies will never be venture-backed, and don’t need to be. And there is an abundance of talent that wants to get to work: people between jobs, experienced operators with no easy way to invest their time.

The usual funding options are leaving too many strong companies and potential investors on the sidelines. Banks rarely lend against a software build or a sales team. Equity forces a valuation nobody can defend, costs the founder ownership and options, and pays off only in a sale. Minnesota has ample talent and capital. What’s missing is a framework that puts them to work together.

There’s a Minnesota way to do this, and we’ve been doing it for more than a century. By 1928, nearly half the nation’s cooperative creameries were here. Dayton’s committed 5 percent of its profits to the community in 1946, and 30 years later 23 Minnesota companies made that a shared standard through the Keystone Program. Different eras, same idea: when we create value together, more of us should share in the success. That’s the next Minnesota model: all of us investing what we have, time or money, and sharing in the upside.

The Shared Success Agreement is a new model for building big things together:  an open-source deal structure I created here in Minnesota. I’ve been on every side of these deals for nearly 20 years, as founder, builder and investor, and I’ve seen more than 50 of them across a wide range of outcomes.

The first was my own, in 2008. We ran a services business that paid the bills, and we saw a product opportunity we couldn’t fund. A developer invested a portion of his work in exchange for a percentage of the new product’s revenue until he’d earned twice what he put in. He earned his 2x, the agreement ended, and we still owned the whole company.

The same mechanics work for money. Say a local investor puts $25,000 into a company for 1 percent of revenue until he’s received $50,000. If the company reaches $5 million in sales over four years, he earns his 2x. Because payments start with the first sale, he can put them to work in the next company while this one keeps growing.

A developer who takes half her fee in future revenue carries the same risk as an investor writing a check. And everyone at the table is focused on the same thing: growing revenue.

You don’t have to be an accredited investor to invest capital, and you don’t need capital at all to invest your time. A strong economy can come from a broad base of growing businesses where the people who build them share in what they built.

It’s already working here. GovDocs, Nice Healthcare and BackpackEMR all used revenue-share agreements to fund development, and Minnesota investors like Hill Capital, TinySeed and Venn Foundation structure deals the same way: the founder stays in control, and investors are paid back from growth over time, not only at an exit.

So let’s get to work. Builders can take part of their fee as a capped revenue share. Investors can add revenue share to deals they consider. Founders can put it on the table before equity; we’ve done it with our own team, and it works. Equity still has its place for venture-scale companies and pre-revenue ideas. For everyone else, this belongs on the table.

The next time a founder needs talent or capital to grow, there’s another answer besides an invoice or a term sheet: let’s get started, and share in the upside of what we build. Minnesota has shown the country how to share success before. Let’s be the state that makes the next Minnesota model the standard everywhere.

Zack Steven is founder and CEO of Cloudburst Studio in the Twin Cities and creator of the open-source Shared Success Agreement.