Opinion
Opinion

High Taxes, Low Results

Minnesotans pay a lot to rank among the best, but lower-tax competition is beating us.

High Taxes, Low Results
High Taxes, Low Results

I’m the fortunate product of family that had scant resources and did the best it could in a state abundant with helpful neighbors, problem-solving farm kids and a public education system that was the envy of most other states. Trips to Wisconsin and the Dakotas were memorable in part because of how much smoother the roads were once we crossed back into Minnesota.

I later came to realize what made much of that possible was the state’s unique and diverse range of major industry players, from 3M, General Mills and Cargill to Dayton-Hudson (Target), Best Buy, Medtronic and UnitedHealth Group. Leaders from these and other businesses gave back to our communities, mentored up-and-coming trailblazers and funded thousands of startups that went on to become successful businesses that, in turn, supported our community with more jobs and charitable contributions.

I—and, I think, most other Minnesota natives—took all this for granted, believing it was self-sustaining. Many still believe this. But it’s not, and we’re losing ground as other states have spent years figuring out how to outflank us.

We’re still an awesome state in which to work and live for a variety of reasons I’ve written about over the years. But Minnesota is no longer a leader in public education. Our roads and bridges are now worse than our neighbors’. We’re losing major corporate headquarters (most recently G&K Services, St. Jude Medical and Valspar). We’ve gone from one of the best places to start a business to one of the worst. And we’re losing hundreds of our most successful business leaders—from entrepreneurs to industry titans—as they move to states that are friendlier to business and less pernicious with their tax policies.

The three states Minnesotans move to the most—Florida, Arizona and Texas—are beating us not only with better weather, but with better college readiness, roads and bridges, and other infrastructure (see chart). They also have no or low personal income tax, and the fourth-, 21st- and 14th-best overall business tax climate ratings among states, respectively. In comparison, Minnesota has the second-highest personal income tax rate and the fourth-worst business tax climate rating.

Almost a year ago, Twin Cities Business published a comprehensive analysis of wealth migration from Minnesota and found $1.5 billion in taxable income and $22 billion in gross estate value left the state, or began leaving it in 2014 or 2015 because of the state’s taxes and tax policy. (See the full report at bit.ly/1UJaWyA for the full report.)

Some have since said to me that, while we have high taxes here, it’s for good reason as our state has some of the very best publicly funded programs. I certainly remember when that was true, but it’s not anymore, and we’re chasing away those who could help us regain such status.

To get our mojo back, the administration and Legislature need to stop treating financially successful individuals poorly and instead, try to attract more of them like other states, such as Florida and Texas are doing. A high percentage of Minnesotans moving there are people in their 40s and 50s who not only appreciate paying no income tax, but know those state governments welcome them, in part, with much better overall business climates. Texas alone has gained 58,000 former Minnesota taxpayers since 2000, according to the Tax Foundation.

Indiana, Ohio, North Carolina and Tennessee have turned more tax friendly as well. They found ways to reduce high personal income tax rates and some corporate rates by eliminating loopholes or adding taxes elsewhere. North Carolina, for example, added new sales taxes on repairs, installation and maintenance. (See bit.ly/1YwkM6X for more examples of what other states have done). As Minnesota’s population shrinks (minus immigrants), other states’ populations are growing, increasing their tax revenues without increasing (or even after reducing) tax rates.

So what can we do here?

To make us more financially welcoming, we could convert to a flat tax. North Carolina’s personal income tax rate was cut to a 5.57 percent flat tax rate in 2013; the corporate rate was cut as well. Tax revenues rose 6 percent and 188,000 new jobs were created as the tax reform attracted business leaders and investors, some from here.

We also could increase the threshold for our top-tier personal income tax rate. This state has the most expensive combination of low threshold (household income of $259,200 or more) and high tax rate (9.85 percent) in the nation, second only to California. The household income should be increased to $500,000 for top tier payers.

To help pay for these changes, we could eliminate dozens of sales tax exemptions currently provided for special interests such as poultry feed, ski areas, logging equipment, horse feed and medications, and aquaculture production equipment. And we could finally address the biggest lost tax-revenue opportunity of all: clothing tax. Only three other states totally exempt clothing from taxation; four others have partial exemptions.

Sacrilege, you say! After all, what would happen to the Mall of America? I don’t know. But if we’re willing to forgo a major source of tax revenue, we should have an independent analysis of exactly how much economic benefit Minnesota receives from not taxing clothing and compare it to how much we could gain if we decide to tax it.

I’m sure there are several counterpoints to these ideas. But we need thoughtful discussions of what we can do to correct our present course. If it remains as is, Minnesota will someday be known as the once great state that lost it all to others because it sat on its laurels and chased away its most economically important citizens.



* In U.S. News & World Report’s Best High Schools 2016, the highest ranking for a Minnesota public high school is 227th (St. Anthony Village Sr. High); Arizona, Florida and Texas have several public high schools that rank much higher.

Sources: U.S. News &World Report, Best High Schools 2016; American Association of Civil Engineers 2013 Report Card for America’s Infrastructure (2017 report is due out in March); Reason Foundation 21st Annual Report on the Performance of State Highway Systems, 1984-2012; America’s Top States for Business 2016, CNBC; Tax Foundation’s 2017 State Business Tax Climate Index; and U.S. Census Bureau.

Comments

xzktivxbsg
yH7voq <a href="http://womtotmcgbwb.com/">womtotmcgbwb</a>, [url=http://zkvrixcieqyl.com/]zkvrixcieqyl[/url], [link=http://mgbblgomfzjo.com/]mgbblgomfzjo[/link], http://ytrtwdqzqwzz.com/
3/5/2019 10:12:09 PM

vyyqhifijtq
6QwHJ8 <a href="http://jczedljuqdfm.com/">jczedljuqdfm</a>, [url=http://mfmpzxdfchtq.com/]mfmpzxdfchtq[/url], [link=http://mkrzwrdtjoxb.com/]mkrzwrdtjoxb[/link], http://vidxkiwxxejs.com/
3/5/2019 3:56:39 PM

wzcbklfcym
VKMz8t <a href="http://quinnupvlgxq.com/">quinnupvlgxq</a>, [url=http://rcpamxlyuxbm.com/]rcpamxlyuxbm[/url], [link=http://ebedwrxeynzp.com/]ebedwrxeynzp[/link], http://iogkdzneurgf.com/
2/5/2019 4:50:56 AM

mtrvukockk
lc2R1l <a href="http://suaesphpclpg.com/">suaesphpclpg</a>, [url=http://nxakzgskwkjn.com/]nxakzgskwkjn[/url], [link=http://cjzoeljbcnjy.com/]cjzoeljbcnjy[/link], http://crejpgynilku.com/
2/5/2019 3:23:04 AM

trxtpszeel
K5erjz <a href="http://mqhzwngsktmi.com/">mqhzwngsktmi</a>, [url=http://rswispxfpiyx.com/]rswispxfpiyx[/url], [link=http://twxkzskgplor.com/]twxkzskgplor[/link], http://hdhdjaiesbxr.com/
1/21/2019 11:56:55 PM

gdrqivmk
QcLBbm <a href="http://fctktcjyzalx.com/">fctktcjyzalx</a>, [url=http://krywttetwwal.com/]krywttetwwal[/url], [link=http://ratdtaoigcbx.com/]ratdtaoigcbx[/link], http://sntgzkkphacl.com/
1/21/2019 11:55:49 PM

tmfcioa
IBbdyk <a href="http://mniqxgqyopvr.com/">mniqxgqyopvr</a>, [url=http://xckpwbzagonu.com/]xckpwbzagonu[/url], [link=http://osnhkykaggud.com/]osnhkykaggud[/link], http://jnurgmxpyhyj.com/
1/21/2019 11:53:35 PM

dlsloqq
jupkYT <a href="http://bwslunuzhcqq.com/">bwslunuzhcqq</a>, [url=http://dzwtjnchrvzc.com/]dzwtjnchrvzc[/url], [link=http://cloyygxmvrll.com/]cloyygxmvrll[/link], http://hvhnzyxthtgo.com/
12/20/2018 6:34:24 AM

fqiuxhnn
Js5xOW <a href="http://ixebyoqjmpln.com/">ixebyoqjmpln</a>, [url=http://ubywblpgtohe.com/]ubywblpgtohe[/url], [link=http://pmirrwqqfqec.com/]pmirrwqqfqec[/link], http://xzxsybrwrsnv.com/
12/20/2018 6:16:48 AM

ofqrwbee
7COrQS <a href="http://rhhstqorpgft.com/">rhhstqorpgft</a>, [url=http://geverkcwxcxo.com/]geverkcwxcxo[/url], [link=http://hoeoakabaxru.com/]hoeoakabaxru[/link], http://waaliqsbbqdo.com/
12/20/2018 6:07:26 AM

Tracy
Could you please repeat that? <a href=" http://soprof.com.mx ">levitra</a> Theocharides is supposed to pay her ex-husband 500 euros a month under a local court's shared-custody decree that is supposed to guarantee her visitation rights. According to Theocharides, her ex-husband, Charis, is a business consultant for NCR (National Cash Register) in Nicosia and makes 4,200 euros a month, information she says she got from court documents.
12/10/2018 3:30:36 PM

Mohamed
Another service? <a href=" http://vvasoftware.com ">ventolin</a> "Following an investigation, the police have today arrested nine Heathrow employees. The employees in question have been suspended while the police complete their investigation. We take any report of criminal behaviour seriously at Heathrow and will be taking appropriate action if there is a case to answer."
12/10/2018 3:30:28 PM

Dustin
I'm a housewife <a href=" https://weteachquran.com ">levitra</a> TDF owns television and radio masts, as well as satelliteand internet operations. Prospective bidders could be hesitatingbecause a recent network sharing deal between two of itsclients, Bouygues Telecom and domestic rival SFR, could mean afall in business, one of the sources said.
12/10/2018 3:30:20 PM

Brian
Do you know the number for ? <a href=" https://matrixglobal.net.id#sock ">ventolin</a> The team, however, did sign veteran free-agent linebackers Jamar Chaney and Omar Gaither, who were initially drafted by the Philadelphia Eagles. Chaney played in 44 games with 23 starts in three seasons with Philadelphia.
12/10/2018 3:30:15 PM

Santiago
We'd like to offer you the job <a href=" http://vvasoftware.com#states ">kamagra</a> "I took the decision to do this precisely in the next two concerts, after learning that he had been sanctioned with an indefinite suspension from concerts and other public activities sponsored by the ministry," Rodriguez said in his blog, Segunda Cita (Second Meeting), on Tuesday.
12/10/2018 3:30:11 PM

Bryce
I've just graduated http://soprof.com.mx diflucan “He should,” Kershaw told Foxsports.com last week. “There’s no reason, especially if it’s in New York, that he shouldn’t start. That’s what the fans will want. I’ve got no problem with that.”
12/10/2018 2:29:35 PM

Duncan
What university do you go to? http://vvasoftware.com cialis For being in the game at all England had to thank Ian Bell for playing one of his most valuable and mentally strongest innings. Responsibility devolved upon him after Alastair Cook and Kevin Pietersen were dismissed either side of noon, and he responded most maturely with 56 runs off 134 balls by tea.
12/10/2018 2:29:30 PM

Orval
Can you put it on the scales, please? http://soprof.com.mx ventolin Gold has fallen 17 percent this year as some investors lost faith in the metal as a store of value and on speculation that the Fed will reduce stimulus. Officials will cut debt purchases at their next meeting on Sept. 17-18, according to 65 percent of economists in an Aug. 9-13 Bloomberg survey.
12/10/2018 2:29:26 PM

Weston
How do you know each other? https://weteachquran.com viagra "So the students leave and then there is even less support for that district or that school," said Maria Ferguson, executive director of the Center on Education Policy at George Washington University. "All that money goes with them. Then you're just left with a school with not enough students and it's not very good and it's sure as hell isn't going to get any better in that situation."
12/10/2018 2:29:19 PM

Wilton
Wonderfull great site https://weteachquran.com cialis Jessica Alba was spotted heading into the blue waters of St. Barts and, boy, did she look good! The actress and mother of two, who became famous for her bikini body in the 2005 movie "Into the Blue," is still in tip top shape nearly a decade later. Alba and her husband Cash Warren were vacationing in St. Barts on April 4, 2013.
12/10/2018 2:29:13 PM

lzucrzz
rp9iP7 <a href="http://pbykcmoydsub.com/">pbykcmoydsub</a>, [url=http://vfikahddntrv.com/]vfikahddntrv[/url], [link=http://kkdrpkzvugfk.com/]kkdrpkzvugfk[/link], http://fsnwqlemgeat.com/
12/9/2018 11:27:47 PM

omhrbgh
K3H6OD <a href="http://gmmbdvfbgsmn.com/">gmmbdvfbgsmn</a>, [url=http://bnglrhlvlwhh.com/]bnglrhlvlwhh[/url], [link=http://fnvfclffykzd.com/]fnvfclffykzd[/link], http://tytigjmndvbc.com/
12/9/2018 4:52:16 PM

thwhaiws
n7UjCg <a href="http://fztsgwtnahxh.com/">fztsgwtnahxh</a>, [url=http://wwowvaobgbys.com/]wwowvaobgbys[/url], [link=http://kralyqoemgku.com/]kralyqoemgku[/link], http://zvghytbbgmot.com/
11/5/2018 3:43:31 PM

xlriivc
jl8SJP <a href="http://tsyvhgrvtfdh.com/">tsyvhgrvtfdh</a>, [url=http://slldsiaisrnp.com/]slldsiaisrnp[/url], [link=http://wqxpzsfostpg.com/]wqxpzsfostpg[/link], http://ceunqlmppqdw.com/
11/5/2018 3:32:21 PM

mjyinxu
wfSmlj <a href="http://zhmzoyrbnbxg.com/">zhmzoyrbnbxg</a>, [url=http://dcgptfyncltv.com/]dcgptfyncltv[/url], [link=http://btzrqydhiago.com/]btzrqydhiago[/link], http://zczkbnqswmte.com/
11/5/2018 10:08:19 AM

lknwjfeaqqj
sWCkJz <a href="http://wsmtfsqbulsx.com/">wsmtfsqbulsx</a>, [url=http://shgtcujdxqxl.com/]shgtcujdxqxl[/url], [link=http://kijxjouagelq.com/]kijxjouagelq[/link], http://upwduaobfsqh.com/
8/8/2018 6:13:38 AM

jsmnziaaujv
7mk3Ex <a href="http://oqxjaolhecqp.com/">oqxjaolhecqp</a>, [url=http://qtaugdsnfnel.com/]qtaugdsnfnel[/url], [link=http://kqzqfsibwgbz.com/]kqzqfsibwgbz[/link], http://nciodfgxtwep.com/
8/8/2018 4:38:40 AM

ixodewie
kxaBMk <a href="http://wngusxaadjmq.com/">wngusxaadjmq</a>, [url=http://zweerhdqnomp.com/]zweerhdqnomp[/url], [link=http://wyfvntxkonzb.com/]wyfvntxkonzb[/link], http://ylrcfgoxswxo.com/
8/8/2018 3:03:37 AM

wnzxep
ZcVRSk <a href="http://ciqktncwjmyq.com/">ciqktncwjmyq</a>, [url=http://slepconlvcuc.com/]slepconlvcuc[/url], [link=http://xluohtoeomaj.com/]xluohtoeomaj[/link], http://hyufzbihhvgn.com/
6/26/2018 10:44:09 AM

bcexjhd
z7KgPC <a href="http://juoxkturywzk.com/">juoxkturywzk</a>, [url=http://raofwyluzsmm.com/]raofwyluzsmm[/url], [link=http://lgydzojtzjjw.com/]lgydzojtzjjw[/link], http://ndgjdcjrbplr.com/
6/9/2018 8:05:28 AM

gzoppmtztzs
WNl8TY <a href="http://amwonnioroja.com/">amwonnioroja</a>, [url=http://hiclbpyoibyf.com/]hiclbpyoibyf[/url], [link=http://hprtjxjkypip.com/]hprtjxjkypip[/link], http://sspoeapoeuot.com/
6/9/2018 5:24:04 AM

wtajdhkm
sU73F1 <a href="http://eznupehhpzla.com/">eznupehhpzla</a>, [url=http://nhcczqgajjly.com/]nhcczqgajjly[/url], [link=http://enyzqwkrgpii.com/]enyzqwkrgpii[/link], http://jltoiigbjdmq.com/
5/18/2018 12:02:04 AM

jpvqshna
8gZjkx <a href="http://skqxebcoslej.com/">skqxebcoslej</a>, [url=http://evrrhwkfklih.com/]evrrhwkfklih[/url], [link=http://imvlslffrdfx.com/]imvlslffrdfx[/link], http://yjyfxodxwffm.com/
5/17/2018 10:08:41 PM

cdvjam
rTE8Mg <a href="http://cjgzfvewgmfd.com/">cjgzfvewgmfd</a>, [url=http://wnrmfebxzokx.com/]wnrmfebxzokx[/url], [link=http://ppmxvsucnvum.com/]ppmxvsucnvum[/link], http://zonyouotipxp.com/
5/14/2018 10:50:41 PM

ncknlvis
O2ilwy <a href="http://xqncxsbyukvy.com/">xqncxsbyukvy</a>, [url=http://anzzycmldrpq.com/]anzzycmldrpq[/url], [link=http://noizjvhlxcbn.com/]noizjvhlxcbn[/link], http://uhfvauzhgpox.com/
5/14/2018 4:12:10 PM

pjeyithw
q4J8mS <a href="http://gxwydfowvgto.com/">gxwydfowvgto</a>, [url=http://qqxrepdhaddf.com/]qqxrepdhaddf[/url], [link=http://ommgylpzqmzl.com/]ommgylpzqmzl[/link], http://njvcummjvcpq.com/
5/14/2018 9:41:02 AM

xeedcfdoi
enplMk <a href="http://svdkaywlsaeh.com/">svdkaywlsaeh</a>, [url=http://bkqzppatelst.com/]bkqzppatelst[/url], [link=http://yvoqrwzgigqu.com/]yvoqrwzgigqu[/link], http://rxntgrevonxy.com/
5/13/2018 7:08:02 AM

hbyrodt
zRvovg <a href="http://mxijvyohopup.com/">mxijvyohopup</a>, [url=http://omfjxhpbzlwg.com/]omfjxhpbzlwg[/url], [link=http://zardvumatevk.com/]zardvumatevk[/link], http://jkdjwrphqmaq.com/
5/13/2018 6:45:25 AM

lwlpym
RXakGW <a href="http://xlzpdlydbbzu.com/">xlzpdlydbbzu</a>, [url=http://yumipihocvnh.com/]yumipihocvnh[/url], [link=http://gtopltjorara.com/]gtopltjorara[/link], http://wqtadogxsexi.com/
5/13/2018 5:03:12 AM

jumqagpc
4jj6D9 <a href="http://snmvfypmwfmz.com/">snmvfypmwfmz</a>, [url=http://qdfcyajqbkph.com/]qdfcyajqbkph[/url], [link=http://mvqkmklposgb.com/]mvqkmklposgb[/link], http://rhhfkuvmrmep.com/
5/13/2018 3:23:27 AM

udrlyw
rI13KK <a href="http://akibqjyqgtgr.com/">akibqjyqgtgr</a>, [url=http://qsfdcqyskjbb.com/]qsfdcqyskjbb[/url], [link=http://wqtqunwuktkj.com/]wqtqunwuktkj[/link], http://upkslslelqxd.com/
5/13/2018 1:42:22 AM

Judi
GXA8xK https://www.genericpharmacydrug.com
5/12/2018 1:17:51 AM

mike11
1wOFLb https://www.genericpharmacydrug.com
4/17/2018 4:24:12 PM

uqitxxynln
dVplwl <a href="http://kpuovebpdjzr.com/">kpuovebpdjzr</a>, [url=http://dymaxzimsdds.com/]dymaxzimsdds[/url], [link=http://ertqffgljajt.com/]ertqffgljajt[/link], http://oaqcgnopvawk.com/
4/15/2018 7:23:20 AM

iixdwon
HtMCcL <a href="http://qikfmflulnek.com/">qikfmflulnek</a>, [url=http://pudflbuhubra.com/]pudflbuhubra[/url], [link=http://kncndqsxfqxd.com/]kncndqsxfqxd[/link], http://exvymrogxlpb.com/
12/15/2017 11:09:10 PM

tscevmgciep
PFB7kP <a href="http://ckwrfoxjreoq.com/">ckwrfoxjreoq</a>, [url=http://pmxdscgxrmjq.com/]pmxdscgxrmjq[/url], [link=http://lkiamntrtole.com/]lkiamntrtole[/link], http://fgtmhcmrfubl.com/
12/15/2017 11:05:14 PM

ckolik
LsDMKL <a href="http://fvukisblwgcz.com/">fvukisblwgcz</a>, [url=http://phblzooopjfn.com/]phblzooopjfn[/url], [link=http://wtnmaonajnxc.com/]wtnmaonajnxc[/link], http://qjpnrkslmhjt.com/
12/15/2017 11:01:06 PM

wjxtqz
DMhFHh <a href="http://theyqsduvurj.com/">theyqsduvurj</a>, [url=http://axicguqamqfi.com/]axicguqamqfi[/url], [link=http://waidaltqxnuv.com/]waidaltqxnuv[/link], http://tspmklwdelch.com/
12/15/2017 10:56:49 PM

okpsoupzs
vOzdnR <a href="http://mvkusnrbsepn.com/">mvkusnrbsepn</a>, [url=http://xgvkqxlaabcu.com/]xgvkqxlaabcu[/url], [link=http://dhhmnbjyrihs.com/]dhhmnbjyrihs[/link], http://fkaaefptcbny.com/
12/15/2017 10:51:57 PM

GoldenTabs
ibCTSh https://goldentabs.com/
12/14/2017 7:13:11 PM

Leave message