Renters Warehouse

Founder Brenton Hayden

Founder Brenton Hayden

Renters Warehouse helps property owners profitably manage their leased holdings.

View Acceptance Speech Video
View Biography Video

« Return to main article

In just five years, Brenton Hayden took his idea to help new real estate investors land renters and turned it into Minnesota’s largest residential property-management companies. Age 21 when he started Renters Warehouse, Hayden’s company now manages more than 3,600 properties across the country, and he expects continued strong growth as he franchises the business nationwide.

Hayden was a laid-off sales rep for Kellogg’s in Minnesota when he decided to get into real estate. Working as a broker’s agent, he devised a plan to target novice real estate investors, assisting them with finding qualified renters for their properties. There were few businesses offering this service, and Hayden thought he could add a new twist by dumping traditional classified ads for Internet spots.

“The marketplace was catering to real estate investors, and I wanted to cater to everyday property owners—the ones who couldn’t sell or who inherited Grandma’s house,” Hayden says. “I’ll help [property owners] lease it.”

By placing ads online, handling background checks, and completing showings, Hayden quickly found renters. Just as quickly, he built a network of satisfied customers who began referring others to Hayden. He asked for one month’s rent as payment when he landed a tenant. Soon Hayden was leasing 25 to 30 homes each month, bringing in $50,000 a month.

It was time to formally launch Golden Valley–based Renters Warehouse in 2007. Hayden spent $79 on his Renters Warehouse website, where he listed rental properties. Less than a year into his business, clients started asking Hayden if he also would manage their properties. He figured, “Why not?” The company’s management services include collecting rent and maintaining properties.

Hayden has grown Renters Warehouse through innovative offerings for property owners, including a nine-month tenant warranty. If a tenant placed by Renters Warehouse doesn’t work out or moves, the company will find a new renter for free. And in contrast with competitors, clients don’t pay a retainer fee to Renters Warehouse (they pay on a renter-by-renter basis), and they don’t have to sign exclusive agreements.

Before long, Hayden was adding agents to keep up with demand, and the company today has grown to 32 agents. Along with 63 other employees they have helped Renters Warehouse complete $1.5 billion in real estate transactions. The company landed at 787 on Inc. magazine’s list of the 5,000 fastest-growing businesses in the country. Renters Warehouse is on track to bring in $7 million in 2012. In 2011, the company’s revenues were $4 million; in 2010, $1.9 million.

Hayden attributes the company’s rapid growth to its distinctive selling points for property owner clients, such as $100,000 in property damage protection and a guaranteed rent program for the first six months of a lease. He also publicized Renters Warehouse by advertising heavily on the radio in areas across the country where the company has franchises. Renters Warehouse market research determined that 70 percent of its customers were white, male conservative Republicans between 34 and 55 years old. To reach that demographic, Hayden lined up Glenn Beck as one of his first spokespeople in 2009. Another spokesman is real estate agent and TV personality Josh Altman from Bravo’s Million Dollar Listing, who appeals to a younger, hipper audience.

After Renters Warehouse aligned with Beck, the company made $1 million off of his endorsement. Continually getting out the company’s name is critically important because it constantly needs to attract fresh renters and new clients. And once clients opt for Renters Warehouse they generally stick around, to the tune of a 98 percent retention rate, Hayden says.

Reggie Brown, CEO of AllPropertyManagement .com, a property management lead-generation business based in Seattle, says Hayden tapped into demand from property owners who needed help renting their homes after the real estate market crashed. “He saw this opportunity and he executed on it with a number of great ideas that aren’t being used in the market,” Brown says. “He has a great sense for ideas and opportunities, and more importantly, he developed a way to put them in place more successfully than any of his competitors. He’s taken a lot of market share.”

The engine for future growth comes from franchising, which Renters Warehouse started in full force this year. The company currently has locations in Arizona, Colorado, Maryland, and Georgia.

Renters Warehouse
Location: Golden Valley
Founded: 2007
Employees: 63
2012 projected revenue: $7 million

President and CEO Maureen Steinwall

Steinwall, Inc.

Injection molding company Steinwall, Inc., uses technology to embrace, not replace, its work force.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Co-founder Chuck Anderson and CEO Robert Hartzell

Chuck & Don’s Pet Food Outlet

Chuck & Don’s Pet Food Outlet grew from one to 23 stores in 22 years by selling quality food in a man’s-best-friendly retail environment.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Brothers (from left) Kory, Kyle, and Kurt Kottke

Kottke Trucking, Inc.

Good values and good service helped food hauler Kottke Trucking, Inc., grow throughout the recession.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Director of Brewing Horace Cunningham, Head Brewmaster Michael Kneip, and General Manager Doug DeGeest

Cold Spring Brewing

Cold Spring Brewing refreshes its old business with new craft beers.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Founder Akhtar Chaudhri


Virtelligence is on the cutting edge of health care automation—an edge that legislation has sharpened.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Founder and President Mark Stutrud

Summit Brewing Company

Craft beer’s nothing new—Summit Brewing has been bottling and kegging it for a quarter-century.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Paul Radjenovich, Bonnie Radjenovich, Kathy Felling, Merle Felling, Brenda Jennissen and Patrick Jennissen.

Felling Trailers, Inc.

Felling Trailers, Inc., used the recent downturn to position itself for the recovery.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Angie Franks


Rural health care facilities are essential to their communities—and Healthland’s software is helping them keep up to date.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Tara Watson

Watson Chiropractic And Exceptional Home Health

Chiropractor Tara Watson has overcome floods, tornadoes, and other disasters to build her businesses.

Read Story | View Acceptance Speech Video|View Biography Video

Small-Business Success Stories Finalists

Twin Cities Business recognizes the following Minnesota companies as finalists in the Small Business Success Stories program for their notable achievements.

Read Story

Most Popular

Current Issue


Read this month's issue of Twin Cities Business.